SKIP TO
CONTENT
Barron, Adler, Clough & Oddo Secures Nearly $8M Jury Verdict for City of Lubbock
In October 2025, Barron, Adler, Clough & Oddo, PLLC secured a nearly $8 million jury verdict for the City of Lubbock in a case against the Texas Department of Transportation’s (TxDOT) Loop 88, or South Loop, expansion project. Led by attorneys Christopher Clough, Christopher Oddo and Glorieni Azeredo, the firm prevailed with a legal victory in a rare City-versus-State eminent domain trial, increasing TxDOT’s initial offer of approximately $420,000 by almost nineteen-fold.
About the City of Lubbock v. TxDOT Land Valuation Dispute
The condemnation dispute centered around 14 acres of City-owned land located along Lubbock’s Loop 88 frontage road and near Thomas A. Martin Youth Sports Complex – part of a larger tract the City had carefully maintained for future commercial and public use. Although much of the surrounding acreage had long been designated as parkland for Texas Parks & Wildlife, the City had preserved two corners specifically for commercial development opportunities.
When TxDOT initiated the Loop 88 expansion project, the City followed statutory requirements and secured replacement parkland of equal or greater value nearby. Although Texas Parks & Wildlife had approved the City’s commercial frontage valuation along Loop 88, TxDOT rejected those values and appraised the land it was taking for much less.
“The City did everything by the book, and suddenly the value of the land they were replacing was called into question,” said Barron Adler Partner Christopher Oddo. “Accepting TxDOT’s valuation would have left the City with a multimillion-dollar deficit.”
With millions of dollars at stake, the City of Lubbock decided there was no choice left but to defend its position to ensure it received just and adequate compensation and protect its public resources through litigation. The jury’s final valuation came in at $7,882,175, properly reflecting the land’s commercial value and matching comparable land sales along this corridor.
“Cities and states typically resolve eminent domain issues by coming to an agreement such as cost sharing or a land trade, so this type of valuation dispute is quite rare,” Oddo said.
What this Eminent Domain Victory Means for the City of Lubbock and Its Community
This case sends a clear message to state condemnors: public entities don’t have to accept undervaluation just because it’s the path of least resistance. With the final outcome so far in excess of the original offer amount, this sets a precedent that:
- Cities can secure appropriate, equitable replacement land from valuation disputes with the State of Texas
- Taxpayers shouldn’t be burdened by artificially low valuations
- Municipal landowners should receive fair treatment during roadway expansion projects
Currently, the City of Lubbock v. TxDOT case is ongoing. While the final judgment was issued on December 4, 2025, the State of Texas is expected to evaluate its appeal options.
The City of Lubbock v. TxDOT marks Barron, Adler, Clough & Oddo, PLLC’s second eminent domain case to reach a jury trial in 2025, an impressive accomplishment for any law firm.
“This case’s outcome underscores our commitment to achieving fair and accurate verdicts for our clients who are property owners,” Oddo said. “Our team is proud to have helped the City of Lubbock secure the compensation it deserves.”
If you are facing condemnation through eminent domain, our lawyers are ready to guide you through every step. We bring extensive trial experience, deep knowledge of condemnation law and a proven record of standing up to condemning authorities. Contact our team to discuss your situation and learn how we can help you navigate the eminent domain process with confidence.
Resources: