SKIP TO
CONTENT
Case Study: Successful Jury Verdict Results in a combined $7.35M Settlement in Williamson County, Texas v. J.A. Davidson Holdings
In July 2025, the eminent domain legal team at Barron, Adler, Clough & Oddo, PLLC successfully resolved the long-running eminent domain case Williamson County, Texas v. J.A. Davidson Holdings, L.P. through a comprehensive Rule 11 Settlement Agreement with Williamson County. The agreement involved two different takings for the County’s Corridor C road project, complex valuation issues and over five years of litigation, ultimately resulting in a combined $7.35 million settlement for the landowner.
The County initiated eminent domain proceedings after negotiations over fair compensation stalled, and the property owners faced losing significant property interests. The lawsuit involved separate valuations for different parts of their land parcel. As the case progressed, the County’s offers and the property owners’ valuations remained drastically different, requiring expert testimony, detailed appraisal analysis, multiple legal hearings and a jury trial in one of the two cases.
The $4,437,000 jury trial verdict, delivered in April 2025, was between the Davidson’s two appraiser values but was over $3 million more than the County’s valuation . Additionally, the Davidsons’ patience resulted in a projected interest award on that verdict of over $1 million, which, in turn, created leverage that resulted in the global settlement just a couple of months later. After extensive negotiations, we reached a Rule 11 Agreement that resolved both condemnation cases. Altogether, our litigation and negotiations resulted in a combined $7.35 million recovery for the Davidson family, reflecting the full value of the property taken and remainder impacts.
These numbers represent more than just dollar amounts. They reflect the value of years pushing back against undervaluation, assembling strong evidence from various experts and making sure that Williamson County recognized both the value of what it was acquiring and the true damages to the remainder property.
“Every condemnation matter has its own challenges, but the Davidson case highlights an important point: landowners can and should push for the full compensation they are legally entitled to,” said Barron Adler Managing Partner Christopher Clough. “Through patience, detailed preparation and the active participation of a wonderful family that cared deeply for their estate, our clients received a resolution that accurately reflects the true impact of the County’s takings.”
As attorneys who focus exclusively on eminent domain, Barron, Adler, Clough & Oddo, PLLC is proud to stand by Texas landowners as infrastructure projects accelerate across Williamson County and the state. This case is a reminder of what’s possible when landowners have experienced representation and are willing to see a case through to the end.
If you are facing eminent domain or condemnation, our attorneys are ready to guide you through every step. We bring extensive trial experience, deep knowledge of condemnation law and a proven record of standing up to condemning authorities. Reach out to our lawyers to discuss your situation and learn how we can help you navigate the eminent domain process with confidence.
Resources: